Immigration proposals – a devastating impact on health + social care says law firm


The Government’s new immigration system fails to tackle the deepening staffing crisis in the health and social care sector, according to Royds Withy King solicitors.

The Immigration White Paper severely limits the ability of health and care providers to recruit so-called low-skilled care workers from the EU after Brexit. The new restriction is in addition to existing immigration control on international workers.

Under proposals, employers will have to sponsor workers from the EU and internationally to work in the UK in the future. EU workers won’t get priority for UK work visas, and employers will have to pay each worker at least £30,000 per annum which is significantly more than the current annual salary for care workers.

The UK Government intends to introduce a short term scheme to enable low skilled workers from specified countries to work in the UK for up to one year, however individuals would not be able to extend their stay, or switch into other visa categories in the UK. The government also wants to plug the vacancy gap in certain sectors by extending the current Youth Mobility Scheme to EU countries, enabling individuals aged between 18 and 30 to work in the UK for up to two years.

Helen Murphie, an immigration specialist and partner in the Health & Social Care team said: “There is already a recruitment crisis in the NHS and adult social care, which have 100,000 and 110,000 currently unfilled vacancies respectively. The Government has not listened to care providers who fear that placing restrictions on recruiting workers from the EU will exacerbate the staffing crisis. Many care staff and nurses have left the UK since the Brexit referendum which is putting a strain on services.”

“Measures to extend the Youth Mobility Scheme, and to introduce a short term visa for the low skilled are unlikely to assist care providers in any meaningful way because in both cases they are time restricted and offer little incentive for people from overseas to leave their home countries to work in the UK. The Youth Mobility Scheme is subject to an age limit of 30 and many care workers are older than 30.”

The think tank Global Future estimates, the social care sector will need to employ an additional 380,000 people by 2026 yet is only able to attract just 18,000 new employees a year. Skills for Care estimates 650,000 new roles will be needed in social care by 2035 to meet growing demand caused by an ageing population.

Ms Murphie added: “The picture becomes even more challenging once demand across the NHS is considered. The Kings Fund estimate that by 2030, there will be 250,000 staff vacancies in the NHS, or 350,000 vacancies if the Government continues with proposals to restrict immigration. Staff shortages in the NHS will lead to greater vacancies in social care as the NHS routinely fills vacancies by recruiting from the social care sector.

“The Migration Advisory is currently consulting upon which professions should be included in the Shortage Occupation Lists as part of the UK government’s migration policy. This is an important opportunity for health and social care providers to have their voice heard and we would urge everyone to respond.

“Health and Social Care providers are calling upon the Government to urgently reconsider these restrictions to enable them to have access to care staff from the EU and internationally to ensure the future viability of the health and social care sector.”
The Migration Advisory consultation can be found via the following link:

The work of the Migration Advisory Committee is evidence based and intends to engage with a wide range of experts and interested parties within the short time available to extend and clarify their knowledge. By responding to this online form you will contribute to the range of evidence that they will consider. Migration Advisory Committee’s work will be helped by receiving the best quality evidence from the widest range of people and organisations.  

To access to online form please follow the link below and follow the instructions given:

Please submit your evidence online by 6 January 2019.  


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.