Another day, another damning report on care in England-Letter to the editor

Mike Padgham , chair, Independent Care Group (York and North Yorkshire)
Mike Padgham , chair, Independent Care Group (York and North Yorkshire)

Mike Padgham of the Independent Care Group responds to another report on what is happening in care claiming ‘Damning reports will damage social care further’

Another day, another damning report on the current state of social care. This week it is condemnation of dementia care, last week it was a sweeping generalisation from the Care Quality Commission (CQC) that care is “not good enough at the moment”.

If we continue to batter social care in this way, and to sap what little morale there is left in this cash-starved sector, then believe me the situation is going to get a whole lot worse.

We know that all of us – CQC, government, commissioners and providers – all have work to do in improving the care we offer older and vulnerable adults, as it isn’t perfect at the moment. But there is an awful lot of excellent care out there provided by caring and compassionate people, all year round, that goes unrecognised and unrewarded.

Instead of relentlessly aiming its fire on social care providers – who are going through their toughest ever period – the CQC should be pressing the Government to put more money into social care through a fairer apportioning of NHS funding. Money spent on social care in people’s homes and residential homes avoids expensive hospital care later.

At the moment, the financial squeeze means less and less money being spent on care with fewer people receiving it and standards inevitably falling. If we don’t address this and address it soon then the growing perception out there about the quality of social care will become a self-fulfilling prophecy.

If you tell people often enough that air crashes happen, then people stop flying. If you tell them there is salmonella in eggs, they stop eating eggs. Keep saying social care is poor – and never mentioning that actually, most of it is very good, and people will stop using it and then we will be in a very sorry mess.

Mike Padgham
Chair, Independent Care Group (York and North Yorkshire)

Eastfield House
1 Eastway, Eastfield
YO11 3LS.


  1. I have seen hundreds of care homes over the years. Is there a variation in provision? Absolutely and it would be naive to think otherwise. Some have been sadly lacking and I’m no stranger to homes that have been, or are about to be, closed.

    However, I take exception to the constant battering of care, the sweeping generalisations that are doing the sector (and more importantly, those very dedicated people working in it) a huge disservice.

    Every single day, carers work in what are sometimes very difficult and challenging circumstances. It’s insulting to those that provide great care to hear the blanket statements being issued. By all means, challenge those not doing it properly – the good providers will support you all the way.

    In the middle of all of this care-bashing, let’s not forget the people. Those receiving care, their families and those providing care deserve more than being used as sound bites by people with their own political agenda.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.